I think the first one is a good choice - it is the most classic, but could be dressed up or down easily. I do like the last one with the metal base, but it is too industrial for your space, I think. Cool though :-)

I like the first one your posted. The 2nd and 3rd don't seem to fit the warm colors of the kitchen. The 4th looks fine color-wise, but has an industrial look that doesn't seem to fit quite as well as the first.

I would look for a pedestal table where the legs won’t dictate where you put the chairs.

What is the backsplash material between the upper & lower cabinets now, it is hard to see? I like the idea of taking off the corbels at the bottom of the vent hood, but I would make the entire backsplash area and stove backing area all one complete surface of whatever you choose. It would be a smooth cleaner look and visually enlarge the space. Frankly, I cannot see a round table in that window area, it looks much too small. Consider the space needed for pulling chairs out to sit as well as bodies sitting on the chairs and then walking around them. I would look to a narrow rectangular table with lightweight chairs.

Always choose your chandelier last after you have the furniture in the space. Your choice then will be much easier when you see the whole area furnished. Also, I personally, dislike white ceilings, they always look like they were forgotten, but it is the largest space in the
entire area. At the very least paint them either the same color as the walls unless the walls are dark, then paint the ceilings a very light shade of the wall color.

Look for 3 or 4 backless upholstered stools to slide completely under the island open space. Maybe add a seat fabric for them with a more bold pattern as this a very large space with no pattern. Consider the same fabric on the table chairs as well.

Thanks to everyone!

If it helps at all, the space is 11 ft across and 7' 4" from the windows to the line where the oven starts. The door opens inward so the table would definitely have to be less than 60" long, which seems to be hard to find (except for really cheap boring ones).

I did have my eye on that last table because I do like the industrial style, and I thought it might work with the metal fridge handles, plus perhaps a pendant light and barstools with a little industrial edge. But I see how it doesn't quite go with everything as-is.

Barbara -- the backsplash is a small, rectangular light beige stone with a textured surface:

Maybe you're right about making it all uniform. I was playing with the idea of perhaps finding a Mediterranean tile with a touch of color for behind the range, but I see what you're saying about having a smooth area that's not broken up.

Taking a look at some rectangular tables:

boring but I like the rustic feel.

blah.

Maybe white legs would go well with the lighter countertops.

I actually like the legs on this one when I look at it by itself, but I don't know if it would take the whole style of the kitchen in another direction. These last two are customizable.

The more I looked around, the more I got excited about the prospect of something handmade and customized to fit the space exactly as I need. And some of the options are GORGEOUS, with a rustic feel but a refined finish.

I never really liked furniture style that seemed more traditional, but the more I look at some tables with turned legs, the more I think it might fit the style of the house better. I just don't want to get distracted by things fitting the existing style and forget that I'm trying to update it to look more like MY style. Something like this might be a good blend of the two:

I think I might really like this one ^

SO weird for me to say, with those legs.

That's why I'm struggling with decisions, I don't want things that look out of place but I also don't want to buy things that aren't my style. I'm an over thinker if there ever was one.