The last photo has some of the colors we were exploring.

That was the original plan but due to delivery, the stucco may be done first. In the event that we cannot get the stone installed first, I'd like to have the best option in color choice narrowed down. If I'm not mistaken, the stucco will be applied with the color mixed in as opposed to painted after.

Yes, you don't want to paint stucco, you want the stucco itself colored. You'll want some contrast between the stucco and the stone in order to 'show off' the stone. I like the grey, lower left.

Stucco colored in the mix is old style and these days you don't find the craftsmen that know how, or want, to do it that way.

Our all stucco house in CA (now sold) was painted and we had no issues with it. We used elastomeric paint by Dunn Edwards, which was formulated for that climate and material.

@chispa, The system our exterior guy uses mixes the color into the stucco, which we are happy about . We've owned several stucco homes and have experienced it being done both ways.

With any luck the limestone will arrive prior to needing the color selection of the stucco. I plan to paint large swatches of several colors we narrow it down to.

I am hoping to get some feedback on color suggestions to help guide me.

Hi there. Do you happen to know what grout color you used for your stone work outside

Never select colors from a computer screen.

Limestone varies in color.

Colors differ in different light.

We dry stacked the stone, so no grout. Sorry!

Over a year after your post, I am in the same predicament you were with deciding on a white stucco color with white limestone and black windows. I’m between the SW colors Pure White and Greek Villa. What color did you ultimately choose and do you have a current photo that you could share?

Take a sample of your stone into the tech person at SW for a paint match of one of the light areas. Have them mix a quart with the formula and test it on the stone piece outside at your site.