Those are not my kitchen floors. Photo was taken at kitchen design showroom.

You're building, you're remodeling? You have an island now? Or you don't?

There are a thousand whites between the two you reference. We have no idea your floor.

A kitchen is layout first, then a marriage of finishes to include cabinets, counter and flooring. Creating harmony.........

Thank you! I agree the color they offered was too bright white. We are looking to pick a SW color

Try SW Frosty White. It's a nice neutral off-white and would look great with the oak.

Who are "they" ?

You are buying new cabs in a new build ? It is lovely when we don't need to drag full information out of any question.

"These are not my floors" ....and they are what? What are the tentative counter selections?

You might also show the layout, which believe it or not is THE most important aspect in any kitchen. Trust me on that : )

there may be more gray that comes through w finish on oak after installed in space....use white background for any counter choice and thats enough white... oak finish also seems to have extremely lo sheen..nearly matte. I might get away from the whites entirely for the perimeter and pick a light grayish green to enhance the wood tone . you really have to put that sample door in your space..... i think you have grays at play.

I would veer into a shade like these for your 2nd cabinet color with the oak island...

Kellogg Road Residence · More Info

Monticello Drive · More Info

The one is too bright. The other seems quite vanilla/yellow on my screen, but it's appropriateness entirely depends on your lighting in your own space. Could appear "white" in the right space, or could look like a tuscan yellow.

Pick your counters first and then the white paint color that goes best with it.