Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry
4 Houzz Badges
2550 Stiegel Pike
Schaefferstown, PA 17088
2550 Stiegel Pike
Schaefferstown, PA 17088
Plain & Fancy manufactures custom cabinetry, right in the heart of Pennsylvania Dutch country. We make cabinetry for any room in your home. We can build exactly what you want for your kitchen, library, office, bath, laundry or any other room in your home. We can produce the shelving, cabinetry and desk for your home library or office, the entertainment unit for your family room or home theater, the retractable cabinet for your flat screen TV, the mantel for your fire place or corner cabinet or armoire for that special location in your home. This is just a glimpse at what Plain & Fancy can offer. We are proud to manufacture cabinetry that you can customize to fit your own individual needs.
88 Projects for Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry
Load Next 12 Projects
Robin Road Remodel
Spring Mill Renovation
Plain & Fancy Cabinetry - Oakwood Ohio
Plain & Fancy Kitchen - Dayton Ohio
Saddlebrook Bath Renovation
Escape to the Coast
Rustic Meets Modern
Designed for Living
Write a Review
13 Reviews for Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry
Load All 13 Reviews
The paint is chipping and doors are not square. I have never seen paint chip off cabinets. Very disappointed with the quality after being sold on the quality of the cabinetry! If I was able to do it all over again I would not purchase this kitchen. So sad I’m stuck with it now. Their answer to the paint chipping issues. Touch ups! Such a joke!
December 30, 2019
Working with a company like Plain and Fancy offers so much... a family owned company who cares about you and your project every step of the way, a company that can make anything you ask them to, a company that has one of the most beautiful finishes I have ever seen... As a dealer I can's say enough about how incredible this company is to partner with.
August 1, 2019
Zobel and Co. Kitchens
I've been working with Plain & Fancy for over 25 years. I can't say enough about the quality of their product, very easy to work with, and their designs are on-point with industry trends. I have literally done hundreds of kitchens with them and look forward to doing hundreds more from my new showroom in Glens Falls, Zobel & Co., as well as with Majestic Kitchens in Mamaroneck NY. Hard working, creative, client-centric company.
May 22, 2017
Right Angle Kitchens
Always the finest quality in fit and finish. We are over the moon with their customer service. They always there to help bring life to our custom designs. We could not ask for a better partner in the Kitchen and Bath industry. We appreciate the continued quality service and product. Thank you!
May 12, 2016
Secured through kitchen store
We installed new Plain & Fancy kitchen cabinets and center island this past year. We also put in a new Plain & Fancy cabinet in powder room. The end product turned out well but the production of the items was a major problem. The center island came in 12 inches too wide with 12 inches of dead space in the middle. Plain & Fancy offered to replace it but that would mean weeks delay in finishing the kitchen so our contractor cut and reassembled the island. The powder room cabinet was even worse. The sink could not be installed because there were boards in the middle of the sink hole. In addition the drawers and doors were not aligned. Plain and Fancy did replace the cabinet but did not cover the extra cost of having contractor, electricians, tilers, and painters come back again. Months later I still cannot see how they could have made such a mistake in manufacturing these items. Again the finished product was great but Plain & Fancy offered nothing to offset our troubles or expenses. .
September 15, 2015
Comment from Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry:
Thank you for your response. We regret that you had an unpleasant experience with our product. As the manufacturer, we build our cabinets to the specifications that were submitted and approved by the dealership you ordered through. However, we would like to invite you to reach out to us if you'd like and if there was error on our part we will do our very best to correct that for you. Please feel free to call us at 1-800-447-9006 or email us at firstname.lastname@example.org.
Delicious Kitchens & Interiors, LLC
What a privilege to sell these fine products... it's easy to see why the family-run business continues to thrive; now nearly 50 years. The quality materials and craftsmanship speak for themselves and their stylish options continue to evolve as the times demand. From traditional shaker and painted styles to contemporary veneer options the selection is never ending and special colors are common. Their agreeable customization department works with me to bring my client projects from rough concepts to completion through engineering and collaboration. Arched doors, bow-front cabinetry or unique mullion designs are all within easy reach. When quality is important Plain & Fancy is my "go-to" for clients and those clients are never disappointed.
August 5, 2015
George Davis, Inc.
Plain & Fancy Dealer
We love using Plain & Fancy cabinets for our projects. They are built very well and finished beautifully. We are able to design our own pieces, use unique woods that you can’t get with other lines, and the door styles and finishes are endless since they can also be customized. Recently, we renovated a cottage and there was such limited space that we were able to use their frameless cabinets for maximizing storage. Since we could do custom sizes, we used every inch and there were no unnecessary fillers. You can’t beat Plain & Fancy if you are doing a large custom kitchen. They carry all the accessories and options that our customers are looking for and the attention to detail is impeccable. From a dealer perspective, they are a great company to work with and we highly recommend them.
July 16, 2015
Inspiration Kitchen and Bath
We offer Plain and Fancy Cabinetry in our showroom at Holod's Kitchen and Bath. This is a new addition to our showroom and displays will be coming in the future. We do have a nice selection of Plain and Fancy's beautiful cabinet doors on display.
May 9, 2015
Granite State Cabinetry
Plain & Fancy Custom Cabinetry is full custom handcrafted cabinetry. It is evident that the many hands making these cabinets take great care and pride in their work. The inset cabinetry offered by Plain & Fancy is simply second to none! Their artisans create finishes that simply are signature to the brand and their followers. They are considered to be the finest in the industry. The hand finishing process coupled with European automated finishes result in a silky and durable consistent beauty.
February 20, 2014Last modified:May 6, 2014
We have been a dealer of Plain & Fancy Cabinetry for over 20 years now and absolutely love their products and service. Everyone who works at P&F from the Reps to the Engineering Staff are delightful to work with. They are a true american, family owned cabinet company that never compromises on quality or craftsmanship!
March 22, 2013
The Kitchen Place
I am a kitchen designer in the Dayton, Ohio area. We have been in business since 1983...now in our 30th year! In 2001, we added the Plain & Fancy line of cabinets to our showroom dealership to fill the void of a high end custom line. We are very picky about the lines we add and research them extensively before signing on. They must have several criteria: good customer service department, use their own trucks for delivery and quality finish /construction. Having been in the business for 30 years, we have used many different cabinet lines. Plain & Fancy is by far, my favorite. In the thirteen years that I've sold this cabinet, I have not had one issue with the cabinets....not even a damaged door or box....not a factory flaw or mistake. They are close to perfection. This is highly impressive as most cabinet manufacturers tend to have SOME damage every now and then. I think where P&F shines the brightest, is their painted finishes. Their enamels in a LOW SHEEN are stunning. Their ultra-matte CLEARTONE finishes feel buttery soft to the touch! P&F has invested in top of the line finishing equipment...and it shows! P&F offers two types of cabinet construction: (Vinyl vs Wood) Vinyl has has a vinyl clad interior that looks like a natural maple. Or you can get an all wood cabinet with veneered interiors. Both have ply sides. I personally feel that the vinyl interiors is smart choice. Save your money (All wood adds $1800-$2500 on an average sized kitchen) and put towards nicer appliances, nicer countertops or some nice accessories. I do have some clients that insist on all-wood and I don't argue with them. The vinyl vs all wood debate has been going on for years in this industry. Both are fine. They both have their pros and cons. Over the years, I have probably designed and installed up to 40 P&F kitchens. All of my customers were 100% satisfied (actually more in love) with their cabinets. Plain & Fancy makes my business look good and I will continue to buy from them for YEARS TO COME!!!
March 5, 2013Last modified:May 24, 2013
We purchased this company's cabinets from a individual who was redoing with cheaper contemporary cabinets. They were 2 years old or less.
We looked high and low for quality cabinets when doing a kitchen makeover. The Plain and Fancy cabinetry we now have in our kitchen is amazing! We feel blessed to have such quality cabinets. Our intention was to redo our kitchen so we could put our house on the market for sale. We love our new kitchen so much that may not happen for a while now!
February 7, 2013
Commented: what’s the gray paint color on the walls@Joe Simon Is this something you could help out with?
January 9, 2020
Commented: Countertop InformationHello. I apologize, but since this is a real homeowner's kitchen we are not privy to that information. We only manufactured the cabinetry. I wish I could help you further.
December 10, 2019
Commented: Shower grout colors?Hi there. Unfortunately for we do not have any of this type of information.
October 3, 2019
Commented: beautiful kitchen and designHello, thanks for inquring. I apologize but these are real consumers kitchens. We have information on the cabinets, but we are not privy to other information regarding the remodel and most homeowners ...
August 23, 2019
Commented: Backsplash questionHello, unfortunately this is a real consumer's home and we do not catalog that type of information as it is not something many homeowners are willing to share with us.
July 31, 2019
Commented: CABINETSHI there. Yes, i'd be happy to help you with this info. This finish is a custom matched paint and and glaze and it was done on Maple wood. The door you see is our Tapestry door.
June 19, 2019