Shop Products
Houzz Logo Print
landlady_gw

Rose Slugs Revisited

landlady
12 years ago

I just came in from my morning wander around the garden/yard which includes the squashing of hundreds of rose slugs. And I have some questions. I probably have read the answers at one time or another but....I forget a lot and very easily.

So: Are the sawflies that would come after the larvae good guys or bad guys?

And: Is there any way, short of spraying, which I prefer not to do, to break the cycle?

And: I forget what the other question was

Comments (5)

  • roseseek
    12 years ago

    They exist to eat plants. The best control is to live where it's too hot and dry for them to live. Those types of climates are also where it's too hot and dry for most diseases, so your pressure to spray anything for any reason is greatly reduced. But, those are also the climates which DEMAND air conditioning and more water for gardening. Kim

  • michaelg
    12 years ago

    The harm that the adult sawflies do is to lay eggs which become rose slugs.

  • landlady
    Original Author
    12 years ago

    Well, their only upside to date is to give me a 'green thumb' (and forefinger too).....:-))))

  • landlady
    Original Author
    11 years ago

    Me again with more questions about these voracious little beasts. Can you remind me: do the larvae that we see on the roses (that eat the leaves to lace) lay more eggs? or is that only done by the adult sawfly? And when does that happen in the cycle? If I am squashing the larvae, which I am !!!!, is there another part of the puzzle? Is there a time when eggs can be eliminated? These guys really are getting the better of my 250+ roses, and I think my squishing and squashing is not keeping up.

  • reg_pnw7
    11 years ago

    Basic entomology lesson #1: Larvae are immatures. Adults are matures. Only mature organisms can reproduce. (glossary definition: mature = capable of reproduction.)

    basic life cycle of insects: egg, larva, pupa*, adult. Eggs hatch to larvae. Larvae eventually pupate to adults, in insects with complete metamorphosis*. Adults lay eggs or otherwise produce the next generation of larvae.

    *Those with incomplete metamorphosis do not need a pupal stage as the larva is much like an adult without the reproductive organs. Aphids and grasshoppers have incomplete metamorphosis. Larvae look much like adults and there is no pupal stage. Sawflies and butterflies have complete metamorphosis - the larva is very different from the adult and there's a complete change in body in the pupal phase.

    My own experience with rose slugs is that squishing will not keep up and spraying with a systemic insecticide will be necessary, the sooner done the better. As soon as squishing is no longer keeping up.