I am open to other ideas as well.

Here are some that might look good with your fireplace.

Wow.. A tad out of my budget but I get the idea. Thank you Lars.

Ooh la la

Ballard Designs

These below are from Wayfair. $$ inexpensive.

What a coincidence @BeverlyFLADeziner! I have six of those fixtures saved in my lighting folder. :) Usually I know exactly what I want, but for some reason I’m having a hard time with this one.

If it helps, these are in my dining room, open floor plan. I painted them a more antique brass finish.

This is over my breakfast table

And two of these above my kitchen island

#6 of Beverly’s ideas is my favorite. Your fireplace has a lot of heavy-ish detail. Your other lighting fixtures have a lot of geometric shapes. Not saying any of that is bad at all, just that I think #6 matches the general style without being overbearing or too overwhelming with what you already have. Just a pretty embellishment.

@jaja06 Hm, I never thought of that. Maybe I was trying too hard for the fixture not to get lost because the fireplace IS so heavy. But I see your point about choosing something softer so they are not competing. Thanks!

You could consider plaster or alabaster sconces that are translucent.

I like number six as well.

I quite like your option #1, as it suits room, looks like the right size and works well with the dark fireplace screen as well as your other lighting.

Then I’d add a dark piece on mantle to create a more layered look vs pieces being flanked on either side, as height variation is visually appealing.

@Maureen Thanks for your vote and suggestions! I did have two varying sized topiaries in brown pots but removed them because they were faux. I always wanted to display candle holders on the mantel, it seems so natural. Previously I had the two-light candelabra style sconces and they fought each other (candles candles and more candles!) but I will definitely try it again with whatever I use next. Candle holders would look great with Beverly’s alabaster choices.

@BeverlyFLADeziner The alabaster would tie in beautifully but I had similar sconces in another home back in the early 90s and I don’t want to repeat it. Also I was thinking that the area needs softening with fabric shade?

Other options…

Let’s call this Option A

Height: 27.0 Inches

Width: 11.0 Inches

Depth: 7.5 Inches

Shade Height: 11.00 Inches

Shade Width: 8.75 Inches

Shade Diameter: 11.00

Too feminine? It comes with different finish and shade options.

Option B

Too geometric? As you can see from the fireplace and kitchen lighting, I enjoy quatrefoil but thought this might be going overboard with the same detail?

Height: 32.5"

Width: 14.5"

Extension: 4.75"

Option C

Too heavy?

20.75H x 4.5W x 6D

Option D

Comes in bronze, different glass shade styles.

Option B would be perfect with your other fixtures. It's updated but belongs in your mediterranean home. I also like the first two you posted. A looks a little too delicate, and C and D don't match the style of your home.

@calidesign Very helpful, thanks! I am still leaning toward #1 if it’s not outdated.