Insulation Basics: What to Know About Spray Foam
Learn what exactly spray foam is, the pros and cons of using it and why you shouldn’t mess around with installation
Mariana Pickering
June 10, 2014
Houzz Contributor; Owner/CEO of Emu Building Science; LEED AP BD+C. After spending many years as an architectural designer in the high-efficiency residential Italian market, I now run a company that specializes in advanced construction science and Passive House design. We are located in Denver, Colorado, and Northern Italy, and we work internationally with builders, designers, and manufacturers of high-performance projects and products.
Houzz Contributor; Owner/CEO of Emu Building Science; LEED AP BD+C. After spending... More
While we all wish there were a single answer for any given problem, oftentimes that’s just not the case. This is true for material options for home insulation. Despite what the market says is the most popular insulation material or method at any given moment, the truth is that each individual project has its own set of circumstances that call for a recommended set of options. And within those options, the specifications and installation can have a massive impact on the result.
It’s important to understand each material and how it works within your home’s construction and the environment in which you live. In this new series, we’ll take a look at various thermal insulation types and materials to help you figure out which is the best one for your project.
We’ll begin with spray polyurethane foam (SPF), which, at least in North America, is fast becoming one of the most popular options.
It’s important to understand each material and how it works within your home’s construction and the environment in which you live. In this new series, we’ll take a look at various thermal insulation types and materials to help you figure out which is the best one for your project.
We’ll begin with spray polyurethane foam (SPF), which, at least in North America, is fast becoming one of the most popular options.
What is SPF? Spray polyurethane foam is a heat-activated polymer that is just what it sounds like, a foam insulation that is sprayed into place. It is made by mixing two ingredients onsite using special equipment. The mixture is then sprayed through a heated hose onto the surface that needs to be insulated. As the chemical reaction between the two ingredients takes place and the substance heats up in the hose, the liquid turns foamy, expands and then eventually hardens in place.
Closed-cell and open-cell spray foam. These are the two kinds of spray-foam insulation. Open-cell SPF is the lighter, less dense option; it is the cheaper of the two but has less insulating power (or a lower R-value). Closed-cell SPF is denser and more expensive, can provide a bit more rigid support to certain structures and can act as a water vapor barrier, because it is less permeable.
Closed-cell and open-cell spray foam. These are the two kinds of spray-foam insulation. Open-cell SPF is the lighter, less dense option; it is the cheaper of the two but has less insulating power (or a lower R-value). Closed-cell SPF is denser and more expensive, can provide a bit more rigid support to certain structures and can act as a water vapor barrier, because it is less permeable.
Why is SPF so popular in the United States? Spray foam has the potential to tackle air leakages better than many other insulation options. Because it is sprayed into place, the foam can fill up cavities and block any small holes that could compromise your building envelope. It can be applied to vertical or horizontal surfaces to act not only as thermal insulation, but also as an air barrier. It’s synthetic and does not attract rodents or insects. When applied properly, spray foam can contribute to a successful energy-efficiency strategy.
As with many aspects of the building market, there are variations in what is considered common around the world. Here in Italy, for example, spray-foam insulation has not taken hold of the market as it has in the U.S., for a variety of reasons outside the scope of this ideabook. As a result, it is more difficult to find installers here, although there are versions of SPF available on the European market.
As with many aspects of the building market, there are variations in what is considered common around the world. Here in Italy, for example, spray-foam insulation has not taken hold of the market as it has in the U.S., for a variety of reasons outside the scope of this ideabook. As a result, it is more difficult to find installers here, although there are versions of SPF available on the European market.
Relative ease of installation. This makes it a popular choice for contractors (although see my notes on installation difficulties below). Plus, even though it can be expensive, its relatively high R-value per inch makes it a competitive option. It’s particularly interesting for renovation projects where traditional batt or board insulation may be difficult to insert. With spray foam (as with blown-in insulation), it’s possible to inject the insulation into a wall cavity, for example, or apply it to a sloped surface.
Challenges of installation. As with many building technology solutions, the increasing popularity of a product or method means an increase in misuse and misunderstandings. Unfortunately, nowadays it is quite common to find examples of spray-foam insulation that have been specified or installed incorrectly.
The most common problems with spray-foam applications are:
The most common problems with spray-foam applications are:
- The chemicals were not mixed correctly, and the foam starts to pull away from the neighboring surface
- The chemicals were not mixed correctly, causing lingering odors and health problems for the occupants
- The installers rush through the installation, leaving gaps and holes that reduce the efficiency of the product
- A sufficient thickness either was not specified or was not executed as specified during installation
- The local climate was not taken into consideration, and the temperatures or humidity levels were outside of the manufacturer’s specifications
- In cold climates a vapor barrier was not installed over the spray foam, sometimes causing roof rot
Be aware of greenwash! Closed-cell spray foam in particular, which uses HFCs with high carbon dioxide content, has a very negative impact on global warming. Some manufacturers are claiming that their spray foam is ecologically friendly because it is based on soy or castor. Don’t be fooled by this marketing gimmick. The percentage of soy legally required for them to be able to make this claim is very low. SPF is still very much a fossil-fuel-based material (as are many other insulation options).
Consider your climate. There are too many climate-specific considerations for insulation to include in this ideabook. With SPF, for example, a vapor retarder layer over drywall may be required when using open-cell spray foam (seen here) in cold climates.
Potential health risks. Some people have reported health reactions to the lingering odor than can occur with certain mixes of chemicals, and the Environmental Protection Agency has issued information to make consumers aware of potential health risks, particularly during installation. There is still very little known about the off-gassing potential of this relatively new product, but a standard has been developed to start monitoring it.
It is absolutely essential that anyone working on the construction or renovation of a home using SPF follow the recommended health guidelines. Please don’t think that you can install this in your shorts and T-shirt on the weekend. Consult a professional or do your research.
It is absolutely essential that anyone working on the construction or renovation of a home using SPF follow the recommended health guidelines. Please don’t think that you can install this in your shorts and T-shirt on the weekend. Consult a professional or do your research.
The good news. Learning the pitfalls is just part of being more aware about the consequences of a certain decision. Each and every insulation material has advantages and disadvantages. SPF is a viable solution for certain homes and can offer substantial energy savings if installed correctly. You just need to be aware that, relative to other materials, the installation can be easier to execute but also easier to rush through. Knowing what questions to ask your installer can go a long way toward obtaining optimal results.
Tips for working with an installer:
Your turn: Do you have SPF in your home? What kind of energy savings have you seen? Please be sure to indicate your geographic region when sharing info in the Comments.
More Insulation Basics: Heat, R-Value and the Building Envelope
Tips for working with an installer:
- Hire someone reputable with verified recommendations.
- Make sure the work is monitored by someone other than the installer.
- Do a quality control check before issuing final payment.
Your turn: Do you have SPF in your home? What kind of energy savings have you seen? Please be sure to indicate your geographic region when sharing info in the Comments.
More Insulation Basics: Heat, R-Value and the Building Envelope
Step into a Ferguson Showroom and you'll be surrounded by the latest styles in kitchen, bath and lighting design... Read More
Related Products
Step into a Ferguson Showroom and you'll be surrounded by the latest styles in kitchen, bath and lighting design... Read More
Related Stories
Most Popular
5 Ways to Protect Yourself When Buying a Fixer-Upper
Hidden hazards can derail your dream of scoring a great deal. Before you plunk down any cash, sit down with this
Full Story
Know Your House
Hiring a Home Inspector? Ask These 10 Questions
How to make sure the pro who performs your home inspection is properly qualified and insured, so you can protect your big investment
Full Story
Green Building
Insulation Basics: Heat, R-Value and the Building Envelope
Learn how heat moves through a home and the materials that can stop it, to make sure your insulation is as effective as you think
Full Story
Working With Pros
Contractor Fees, Demystified
Learn what a contractor’s markups cover — and why they’re worth it
Full Story
Green Building
Insulation Basics: Designing for Temperature Extremes in Any Season
Stay comfy during unpredictable weather — and prevent unexpected bills — by efficiently insulating and shading your home
Full Story
Kitchen Design
What to Shop for in Cabinet Hardware and Millwork
Learn about finishing touches for kitchen and bath cabinets to pick the options that will work best for you
Full Story
Kitchen Workbook
What to Know About Working With a Custom Cabinetmaker
Learn the benefits of going custom, along with possible projects, cabinetmakers’ pricing structures and more
Full Story
Bar Stools & Counter Stools
Your Favorite Furniture Under $199 With Free Shipping
By Houzz
Find something stylish for every room
See Products
Green Building
Cool Your House (and Costs) With the Right Insulation
By Kenny Grono
Insulation offers one of the best paybacks on your investment in your house. Here are some types to discuss with your contractor
Full Story
Wood
8 Rot-Resistant Woods for Your Outdoor Projects
No need for chemical treatments on your deck or pergola. These woods stand up to weather, insects and time beautifully on their own
Full Story
You would think NASA would use this for space stations. Ever looked at Aerogel? That I have seen analyzed and also vacuum panels - they both work but have some inhibiting factors relative to use. Nansulate may have effective R Value of something but not a true R value - if it does show me a picture of the label claiming that; certainly that is on the package just like any insulation product. It is probably a roll on radiant barrier - like wrapping a potato in foil. It is effective at limiting the effect of infrared radiation but has virtually no R value - the laws of physics/thermodynamics are fairly absolute (except maybe the first law of TD - cause if it were true we shouldn't be here - unless the universe is a real illusion - the only thing that makes sense - it appears to exist - (for the first law to be valid the sum of the universe has to be zero) - just like Nansulate appears to insulate - no room for magic). I don't need to look further, if there was anything there you would have included it in your response.
Put in insulation and put it in correctly is my advice. If you put on two layers of Nansulate does it give you an R 38 (that is how it works with most insulation)?
Venting an attic or using sun shades or window films can save a lot of conditioning money too but that does not mean it insulates.
If this product hardens what happens if there's a electric or plumbing problem
It sets up - not necessarily hardens like structure foam - yes it is a pain to deal with - take pictures before covering things up so you have to do as little digging as possible. If you think you are going to (planning to) have to do work in the future put the elec in conduit. Pick your battles - better performance or easier repairs.